|
FREE Practice Management Black Paper for Management Consulting Firms
More details...
|
|
"Unjerking" Your Clientele and to Make Your Business Stress-Free
By Tom "Bald Dog" Varjan, Organisational Provocateur
Here is a timely topic right at the beginning of the year.
Quite often
the biggest progress we can make in business is when we remove the
obstacles we have got used to over the years. We are already doing
great, but some fiendish obstacles slow us down. Today we discuss how
to remove one of these nasty obstacles.
At some point in our lives we all accepted projects with
clients who
seemed to be quite nice at the beginning but then turned out to be
clicking time bombs.
Typically what happens is that we try to pick up the slack and take on
more and more to keep the client happy. But certain clients just cannot
be kept happy.
A few years ago I worked with a company and after three months
the
client's monthly sales went up by 27%. Next time I showed up with a
bottle of champagne and suggested a celebratory glass after our
session. The client looked at me and said: "Never mind that. You still
have a lot of work to do before celebrating anything." Shortly after
this the client went off for a two-week vacation and then for another
one, having left me with a message, "I expect you to get these done by
the time I return".
At one point he even mentioned that he would like me to get
rid of all
my clients and dedicate full-time effort to his project because he had
less and less time to participate in the project. He started regarding
me as his subordinate, just because he paid me. My mistake was that I
waited a bit too long before walking away.
So, every now and then we have all come across asylum escapees
from
some of the most pestilential pits of hell, and the sooner we can
recognise these SOBs (Seriously Obnoxious Buyer), the less damage they
can cause to our workflow, cashflow and sanity.
So for a start, you have to define what "Nightmare client"
means to
you. So, here I just give you some "Nightmare client" traits to get
your brain started. Use it as a template and based on it develop you
own "Nightmare client".
Some Warning signs of "Nightmare clients and prospects"
1. They want to keep you under their thumbs - They
believe since
they write your cheques, by hierarchy they are your bosses and you
are their subordinates. That reminds me of a caricature sketch in a
magazine: The elderly tells one of the residents in the lunatic asylum:
"Put down that toy sword and get off that rocking horse, Napoleon. It's
time to go to bed." Make sure your buyer doesn't go Napoleon on you,
and don't give in any kind of hierarchical structure.
You are peers,
and if buyers don't like it they can either take a running jump at the
nearest freight train or go to the river and drown themselves (Yes, I
am listening to the Gun's 1969 album Gunsight, track 3: Go down to the
river and drown yourself. Inspiration is coming out of the woodwork).
Some clients expect you to dedicate your whole life to them and demand
your full attention 24/7. They fail to realise that you have several
clients but only 24 hours a day.
Besides, who the cricket wants to work
24 hours a day. Especially men need lots of micromanaging. For example.
Many women heard this from their spouses, "Honey where are my socks?",
"Which shirt shall I put on today?" Interestingly, most women know
where their knickers and bras are without asking their spouses and they
know which shirt to put on. Just a thought on micromanaging. Watch out
with male clients.
2. They keep moving the project's goalposts - This can
happen
especially if you work on fixed fees. They try to squeeze into the
project's scope as much as humanly possible. They have no respect for
what changes you have to make in your schedule to accommodate them.
Their mantra is: "Since we pay you anyway an obscene amount, why don't
you clean the toilet as well?" Make sure you have the scope of the
project on paper and keep to it.
3. They put you down for every little mistake - These
people don't
accept the fact that you are not a magician. They simply cannot fathom
the basic fact, that when we are aiming at a change of some kind and
some significance, we simply can't get it right the first time. Nobody
does. They expect perfect performance and what is even worse, they
blame it 100% on you.
We know from Ed Schein (Process consultation)
that some 95% of consulting projects fail because clients don't act on
the advice they have just paid for, yet a large chunk of this 95% blame
the lack of result on their consultants. Can you imagine an athlete
coming
second in a race and blaming the coach: "You failed to train me to win.
I demand my money back". Any sensible coach would get on the phone to
the nearest lunatic asylum requesting the immediate collection of the
athlete.
4. They advise you how to conduct your business - Instead
of working
with you to improve their own situation, which they hired you for in
the first place, they gradually become your - unwanted - consultant:
"Your website is really primitive", "You should really rent an
impressive office" or "You should really be available to clients 24/7".
You may have to be pretty assertive with these people and tell them
that you run your business the way you see fit, and they should
redirect their energy to the project. Of course, at this point some of
them may decide to offend themselves (I believe only you can offend
yourself, nobody else).
5. They treat the project as a "backburner issue" in their
lives - The
project is not regarded as top priority. Here you just have to remind
them that the project is getting closer and closer to the projected
completion, but unless they pull their acts together, the project will
expire without completion, and you are only willing to extend the
project for extra investment.
The next step may be, that you ask them
to sign a document which declares that the project has fallen behind
because they don't keep up with the timeline. This document acts like a
bucket of icy water. On presenting this, some clients recover, some get
extremely angry and may even demand your head on a silver platter. At
this point some wimps may say that the client is always right, and good
luck to them.
I see it differently. As a result of their righteousness,
clients created various problems, and hired us to help them solve those
problems. In my experience, every business problem is a personal
problem first, that is habits and behaviours. And this is why we do
clients a great service when we chuck a bucket of proverbial icy water
into their faces. Sometimes you may even have to wallop them a bit with
the bucket over the head to make them see things from a different
perspective.
6. They treat you as a commodity and have little respect for
your
unique expertise - This is the contractor syndrome. They regard
you as
a contractor (outsourced labourer, situational elbow grease, etc.) to
perform activities they have neither time nor inclination for. This is
where so many consultants turn into "fish-catching", and "teaching how
to fish" goes down the drain. Again, you have to be assertive and
remind clients that they hired your brainpower not your brawn power. In
case you do too much fish catching, make 2005 your first
teaching-how-to-fish year. You will see that great clients get better
value and you can expect higher fees, while reducing your workload. And
here is one thing to consider. Imagine that you go to your accountant
to discuss some tax strategies on your real estate investments and then
asking your accountant to go to the tax office, queue up to get the
appropriate tax forms and then bring them to your home because you are
too busy and hate standing in queues? Because this is what so many
consultants do on a regular basis.
7. They put too much emphasis on references and testimonials -
They
don't care what they can achieve with your support and guidance but
blindly focus on what you have achieved with others. They fail to
realise or simply deny the fact that in each equation you are the
constant and the client is the variable, and, using basic maths, the
outcome is the function of the variable, not the constant.
A
relationship with an advisor not only intellectual but also highly
emotional. Just like a marriage. Let me ask you this: Did you marry or
start dating your spouse because references and testimonials from
previous boyfriends and girlfriends said "She is amazing in bed" or "He
is brilliant at fixing cars, TVs and lawnmowers". 80% of a relationship
with a professional is visceral, thus cannot be put into a testimonial,
but this is what the success of the project stands or falls.
And the
other 20% (the intellectual stuff) is just a small contributor.
However, this only applies to truly collaborative relationships. For a
moment parenting comes to mind. You don't have to be a child
psychologist (the 20% intellectual stuff) do bring up great kids. As
long as you offer the visceral stuff, like love (in a professional
sense), care, challenge, guidance, protection, high expectation,
openness, etc. (just like in a consulting gig), you are on the right
track.
8. They repeatedly violate your time by calling you at
socially
unacceptable times - My clients have unlimited access to me, and
since,
instead of a balanced life, I live a seamlessly blended one, they can
call me anytime. But when a client repeatedly calls me at 11PM and gets
outraged because I didn't pick up the phone (because I am asleep), that
is a bit of a problem. I believe in giving clients unlimited access to
you, provided your fees are high enough to justify this level of
access, but I don't believe in being on call for clients. When I happen
to be awake I answer that 11PM call (advantages of the blended
lifestyle), but also tell clients not to expect me to sit by the phone
at 11PM. There must be some ground rules here, so create some for
yourself.
9. They keep reminding you how generously they "overpay" you -
They
keep repeating that they could get greater value for lower fees. They
keep telling you they are with you just as a favour and expect you to
lower your fees if you want to keep them in the long term.
10. They expect you to offer favourable payment terms or chase
them for payments – Well, you are not supposed to pay the role of
the bank. If they need a loan to pay for what you can bring to their
tables, then they should take a loan through the proper channels, that
is, banks.
11. They keep threatening you with legal action unless you
dance to the
beat of their drum - Quite often (hey, almost always) we work with
companies significantly larger than our own firms. And sometimes these
companies sharpen their legal claws to make us do things that are not
part of the agreement. No doubt, they can be intimidating. What I have
found is that saying that "I plan to publicise my experiences" can take
care of the situation. You basically don't say anything nasty. You just
present the facts. As I have found out from a friend in Germany, If you
mention that you plan to keep the press posted on the issue, the client
goes quiet. Sometimes I feel like using some skills I learnt in the
military, but then I realise that it wouldn't go down well, so I find
other options.
12. They frequently miss, cancel or reschedule your meetings -
Again, we are talking about diminishing commitment.
13. They expect you to pick up their slack - Some clients
take
vacations in the middle of projects, resulting in a similar email or
phone message: "I am on vacation in the next two weeks, and this is
what I want you to do by the time I return". The funny thing is that
when you indicate that you go on vacation for two weeks, these same
people get outraged and demand their money back. I believe that
consulting is not about doing things for people but helping them to do
it for themselves. All in all, they have to do the work under your
care, protection and guidance. A nutritionist can give you advice on
weightloss, can help you to create a weightloss plan and can coach you
to execute the plan, but clients can't expect the nutritionist to go on
a diet and then pass weightloss to clients. Clients must implement
their plans under the care, protection and guidance of their advisors.
14. They expect you to go the "extra mile", but they are not
willing to
make "extra investment" for it - It has become expected of
businesspeople - except taxi drivers - to go the extra mile. How silly
is that. Imagine you fly from Toronto to London, and as a good measure
of going the extra mile, the plane turns around over London and drops
you off to Frankfurt. How happy would you be, considering that you
wanted to go to London? What is the extra mile in professional
services? Hey, we are talking about doling out intellectual property.
How do you go the extra mile on that?
How can a funeral director offer
the proverbial equivalent of the baker's dozen? "I can cremate your
dead father now, and for good service let's wallop your mother over the
head and we can cremate her too at the same time for no extra
investment." People also talk about buying little gifts for clients and
sending birthday cards. I disagree here. Instead of sending gifts, I
prefer to spend my time and money to sharpen my skills, which in turn I
can offer to my clients as new value. What is more valuable for a
client?
A life-sized chocolate Santa for Christmas or a process that
helps the client to reduce proposal-writing time by 50%. The way I see
it, Santa eventually exits the body, but the process will stay with the
client, saving her money and time forever. Simply educate your clients
about your practices in case they expect chocolate Santas. Please
remain a professional in your own trade and don't try to become Santa
to your clients.
15. They are your friends and relatives - This can be a
very slippery
slope, landing you in very nasty situations. Let's face it, most people
don't put much value on anything unless they can scratch the window
with it. You can't do that with intellectual property. Many people buy
expensive cars but absolutely refuse to invest some extra dollars to
take advanced driving courses.
They refuse to pay $15 for a private
tutor for their kids, but happily pay four times of that amount to
their hairdressers. I think this is where we can learn from lawyers.
They are good at framing the problem and if you want the answer, then
you get the typical, "Here is my card. Call my office for an
appointment." They just refuse to dole out life-changing advice over
the family dinner-table.
16. Refuse to answer tough questions - Just as
gynaecologists ask their
clients to lie down and spread their legs for diagnosis, you too have
to ask tough questions to establish whether or not there is a mutually
beneficial basis for working together with your prospect. Prospects
must understand that to achieve something worthwhile is neither
comfortable nor convenient (and definitely not cheap), and they must be
ready for participating.
The sooner you start firing the "tough
diagnostic questions", the sooner you find out whether the prospect
says or goes. Hey, dentists ask you to open your mouth after a casual
"Hello". Remember, you are a consultant not a rapport-builder
contractor. S/he is there to point out what you haven't seen and solve
problems.
17. They are in a rush - They have no patience to discuss
various
options for next steps. They tend to say, "That sounds good. Do it for
me." Remember, consulting is supposed to be a collaborative
relationship, not a "do it for me" gig. You and the client do
everything jointly. There is no such thing as "Hey hotshot, do it for
me".
18. They are busy digging for guarantees on results - This
only shows
that have no confidence in themselves and are looking for a scapegoat
just in case something goes wrong. I do believe in offering a fair
guarantee (guaranteeing results is unethical) as part of the gig, but
when a prospect makes a buying decision based on a guarantee, that is a
warning sign for me.
Yes, guarantees can be enticing but trying to make
prospects decide for you just because you offer a guarantee can land
you in deep trouble. Consulting is not like a weightloss pill, which if
you take according to the recommendation (which most people are utterly
incapable of), you lose weight. The consultant's advice must be acted
upon, and that is the client's job, which most clients miserably fail
at. You don't have to take on the client's sloth.
19. They compliantly nod and agree with you on everything - Be
afraid,
very afraid of the of quiet clients. They stay silent for a while,
letting you fly alone without any feedback, but when they finally open
their mouths, it can shatter your eardrums. These clients let you work
on various things, like plans and processes, but then when you pass
these plans to them for approval, you have a long time to wait. And
when the deadline arrives, they call you out of the blue and demand why
the project is not completed yet. Most of these clients expect you to
do everything while they sit back and relax.
20. Hesitates to sign agreement - They try to convince
you to play on a
handshake, knowing that later they can play a bit of scope creep with
you and you have no legs to stand on. Make sure everything is in
writing, so you both become accountable to the same document what you
sign at the beginning.
21. Are looking for the cheapest provider - These people
are not
interested in quality. They buy anything as long as it is cheap. Keep
away from these buyers. Ideally your disqualification process should
eliminate them even before you personally come into the equation of
lead conversion.
22. They are overly transaction-focused - They want you
to come in, do
the job and clear out. The funny thing is that these demands come from
some type A people, who are some of the greatest underachievers in
life. Yes, they achieve great things in certain areas in life, but look
at the price they pay? And they want it the first time around. No
errors, no mistakes are tolerated (apart from the many they make - see
any research on type A people, and how they stumble from mistake to
mistake very efficiently and very blindly).
I think the word efficient
was invented for them: Running very fast often in the wrong direction.
I have recently worked with a hardcore type A CEO of an IT firm on some
health and fitness issues. I showed her the research report according
to which, type A people's average life span is some 15 years shorter
than average folk's. First she shrugged it off, saying "Oh well, that's
me".
After about twenty minutes of chatting about her small
grandkids,
she was more than ready to change her lifestyle. For these people
projects are about financial gain only, and even if you help them to
save a bundle of time and money, they won't respect you because you
didn't actually make any money for them.
23. They insist on paying you on completion - The problem
here is that
they can drag out the completion date as long as they want to. Has it
ever happened to you that you finished the project according to the
agreement, passed it on for final approval, but the approval didn't
happen because the buyer was too busy doing something completely
different? And who pays the price? Yes, you. Make sure you get your
full payment before completion.
24. They suffer from various personality disorders - Some
may be
slightly paranoid, blaming you for everything, including the Second
World War, the fall of communism (sigh of relief) and the Holocaust.
Some are neurotic, blaming themselves for everything, often to such
degree that you cannot reason with them. They use phrases like: "This
is too much for me", "I can't keep up with this", etc. They keep
putting themselves down and consequently act out the shortcomings they
have just brought on themselves. For instance: "I've told you I'm not a
techie", and formats the hard drive to prove the point, losing all
data. We all have abilities to coach clients through some humps and
bumps, but we shouldn't try to deal with people who need psychiatric
treatment. Most of us are not licensed for that.
25. They try to isolate you from the economic buyer - This
often
happens when you work with implementing teams whose leaders want to
take control over you. They know that if they can keep you away from
the buyer, then they - the team leaders - can present progress to
buyers in any which way they see fit, softening their own
accountabilities. So, often, instead of presenting the state of the
project objectively, they present it in a way that is most suitable for
them, knowing that you are out of the picture. Make sure you stay in
touch with the buyer throughout the project and even afterwards. Also
make sure that you too provide a summary to buyers.
26. They promise you lots of work later if you give them
discounts now
- Except that is hardly ever happens. And even if it happens.
Imagine
you go to Air Canada's ticket office saying, "Hey, can you give me a
really cheap ticket to London, and if I like the service, I will use it
every year?" You can't even get such a commodity as plane tickets, let
alone consulting services. Besides, once you get written up in the
buyer's history book as an economical (alright, cheap) alternative, you
will never be able to charge premium fees. And besides that you will
never be perceived as a peer, but rather a pitiful peddler hungry for a
bit of handout. Even worse, you will never be considered for projects
of premium importance. You will get called in to fix crashed hard
drives, but somebody else will be called in to re-design and re-build
the company's network.
27. They want to pay you a percentage of increased sales - This
is
swell. Imagine you go to your mortgage lender and say, "If the house is
as good as you say, then give me the house for free, then I rent out
the basement and pay you a percentage of the rent I collect every
month". Can you visualise the amazement on the face of your mortgage
dude/dudette? Sadly many consultants try to lure in clients by offering
guaranteed results (consulting is collaborative and you cannot
guarantee other people's action). Therefore I believe it is a mistake
to accept percentages.
One service I provide quite often is to design
lead generation and sales automation systems for professional firms
(from first contact to first cheque without any human interaction. Some
call it cold, but I call it time- and cost-effective), so the sales
process is almost eliminated, and prospects come to the first meeting
either with a cheque or already pre-paid. Some firms love chasing
prospects all over hell's half acre, but some prefer to be sought out
in a competitive vacuum.
It reduces prospecting time almost to zero
because it is fully automated (Hey, what is the web for?), and being an
engineer by trade, it is natural for me to design systems and processes
that produce predictable results with minimum human interaction. Yet,
it is still up to them to convert those - although high quality - leads
into paying clients, but there are not many businesses have prospects
come to them to a pre-paid firms meeting. So, I cannot guarantee
increased sales. The desired improvement is something we create
together.
So, what can you do to prevent yourself from being pestered by
inappropriate prospects? Well, the best you can do is to create a very
rigorous and as automated as possible self-disqualification process for
prospects. Look you don't have to start a relationship with a personal
meeting that eats up two hours of your time. Make sure you come into
the equation only after the prospect has made a conditional commitment
to hire you. If your target is small businesses, this rule applies
about a gazillion times over. You have to make sure that your fee
doesn't become funding for a vacation or a new car and the client comes
back to you "I can't afford it now".
If you can automate the whole discovery / disqualification
process,
several great things happen. You consistently get clients with the
attributes. Hey, the form they have to fill in is objective to
everyone. You also drastically reduce the time you spend with people
before they make a commitment to hiring you.
|